Justin Herbert vs J.J. McCarthy

Justin Herbert vs J.J. McCarthy for 2026 NFL fantasy football. Justin Herbert projects for 12.8 PPR points per game; J.J. McCarthy projects for 3.5.

Use the scoring-format totals, ADP and projected role below to make the draft decision. Injury designations: Justin Herbert fit; J.J. McCarthy questionable.

2026 fantasy projection
MetricJustin HerbertJ.J. McCarthy
PPR / game12.83.5
PPR season21760
Half-PPR season21760
Standard season21760
Consensus ADP104.7—